Traditional Roofing vs. New Alternatives

Older Waterproofing Systems Still Survive, But Many Have New Twists
By Dan Calabrese

Rob Cisneros remembers when Cetco began offering waterproofing products for commercial roofing in 1927. Its product was a simple bentonite clay. Okay, he doesn’t remember. But there’s a reason he knows about it: Cetco still offers it.
It’s little more than a piece of corrugated cardboard up against granulated bentonite. Over time, the cardboard biodegrades and the bentonite stays behind.
In a commercial roofing market that sees advanced waterproofing products entering the market on a constant basis, Cisneros, technical manager of Cetco’s building materials group, says there are many situations in which a basic old standby remains a good choice.

Tried-and True
“There’s no reason to put a really high-end product in a situation where something else will do, especially nowadays when you have to be so mindful of budgets,” Cisneros said.
That’s not to say he won’t be glad to sell you the latest product. It just means he wants the product to fit your needs, and not every job needs something beyond the basics.
Annette Smith-Rich, owner of Baltimore-based Rich Roofing, says her company recently completed a high-end job for the Baltimore Convention Center and Hotel, and has just won the chance to subcontract on the roof for the new Defense Information Systems agency building in Arlington, Va.
On both projects, Smith-Rich used Bituthene, a well-established peel-and-stick waterproofing membrane from Grace Construction Products. Calling Bituthene a good performer on both vertical and horizontal applications, Smith-Rice said the five-year-old company finds it best, at least for now, to go with the tried and true.
“We tend to stick with what we know,” Smith-Rice said. “It doesn’t mean we won’t be looking at newer products, but… we know it has the quality we need. I’ve looked into some of the others, and there are great products on the market. But I just wanted to stick with what I know.”
According to Cisneros, basic waterproofing products are finding new markets, thanks to a renewed interest in waterproofing and tight budgets that force roofers to get the most from their money.
“There are new dynamics in this construction market,” Cisneros said. “There’s a lot of price pressure to bring a project in at or below the targeted cost, so you have to make the most out of what you have.”
He says the bentonite roof panels, Voltex and Voltex DS, are popular for the same reasons. “There are areas of Indiana where we still use a lot of these panels. We’ve done a few things to make it better, such as punching it so the bentonite granules stay in place. But it’s simply a mat of bentonite, and in many cases, that’s really all you need.”
Major building product manufacturers offer a mix of old and new waterproofing materials, and in many cases, they split the difference by adding new twists to serve as enhancements to the older products.


Synthetic substitutes are becoming a great alternative to asphalt felt. The recent rise in oil prices has made them more economical than ever before.

New Technologies
Cetco has sought to enhance its bentonite-based products by creating a new line called CoreFlex, a geotextile impregnated with a polymer/bentonite core, lamitated to a thermoplastic membrane.
“It’s the best of both worlds,” Cisneros said. “You’ve got a membrane with heat-welded seams, and every detail is heat-welded and/or terminated, but it has a redundancy, and if there’s damage during construction or post-construction to the membrane, you’ve still got that active waterproofing behind it.”
Cisneros said CoreFlex is often the choice of contractors working on a “can’t-leak” project in which no margin for error is acceptable.
“We have things that are security-related, and that can’t fail,” he said. “It’s a little more expensive and higher-end, and it’s targeted mostly at those types of situations.”
CoreFlex also works well in rehab situations, because it doesn’t require a clean surface to be applied. It’s also available in a green roof version.
According to Cisneros, CoreFlex can also easily replace systems that have reached the end of their useful lives.
Grace Construction Products has released a new product designed to give new life to the traditional inverted roof membrane assembly (IRMA). It’s essentially an upside-down roof in which the membrane is beneath the insulation. IRMAs have typically held their own with single-digit market share for many years. But Brian West, product manager at Grace, said they have found a new life and purpose with the emergence of green roofs.
“You can take most low-slope roofing and make an IRMA roof out of it,” he says. “The current IRMA roof systems are mechanically attached or loose-laid, and they don’t have the waterproofing performance you need for a traditional roof.”
To make the application more viable, Grace has developed the Procor Deck System 3R. Procor 3R is fluid-applied waterproofing for inverted roofs, elevated concrete decks and green roofs.
“IRMA roofs in the past were mostly situations where you would take something existing off the shelf and try to make it work the best you can,” West said. We saw an opportunity to provide a proven waterproofing system in this critical building application.
“There are really two camps out there,” West continues. “There are people who like liquid and people who like sheet membranes. With a liquid you have no seams at all, but you have to ensure proper field-applied thickness. Details are very easy. It’s spray- or roll-applied. A sheet offers factory-control thickness, which a lot of architects prefer.”
For those who go both ways, Grace also offers two hybrid systems, Bituthene Deck System, a combination of a liquid and sheet membrane and most recently, Procor Composite Waterproofing System, a combination of Procor and an HDPE embedded sheet.
“People were using roofing membranes to build IRMA systems, and they realized that traditional roofing products didn’t solve the issues they had,” West said. “We married our long-time technology with their interest in IRMA. The excitement and the interest has really expanded in the last couple of years.


This yellow roofing membrane from Cetco combines old-school bentonite clay with new-age polymers and thermoplastics to create a barrier perfect for “can’t leak” scenarios.

New Twist on the Old
Grace has also introduced a new twist on an old standby system – asphalt felt.
Rising oil prices created an opportunity for the company to offer an alternative to asphalt felt, a product it believed, despite a long history, to be substandard in protecting from leaks and water infiltration.
The new product, called Tri-Flex, is a polypropylene woven mat that is lighter and more tear-resistant than traditional felt.
“Synthetics have been hopping along for a couple of years now,” West said. “A lot of contractors have made the move to synthetics. It has amazing skid resistance, it’s safe to walk on and very dimensionally stable. You can leave it exposed for up to six months before you get the primary roof on top of it, so it gives the contractor a lot of flexibility.”
Synthetics have also become more economically viable since the price of oil has risen and demand for gasoline has dropped, shortening the supply of asphalt and driving up the price of what’s left. In many markets, synthetics are now as affordable as asphalt.
“Today, a contractor can easily make the choice with no financial impact, and he gets all the benefits of synthetics,” West said.

» Download the entire story

 
 
 

HOME  |  CURRENT ISSUE   |   BACK ISSUES  |  SUBSCRIBE  |  ADVERTISERS  |  FEATURED PRODUCTS  |  ABOUT US